Google



The Mediadrome
Search WWW


 

Conditions at Scutari

  from The Times (April 17, 1855)
   
  Conditions for wounded and dying soldiers during the Crimean War became a national scandal back home in England. Florence Nightingale was instrumental in bringing the lackadaisical attitude of the commanders to the attention of the British people. Raised in a political, upper middle class family, she made excellent use of her contacts with the influential Times newspaper. The news of the horrors reached Queen Victoria and Florence Nightingale became the iconic, "Lady with the Lamp."  
     
 

If official correspondence were identical with a bountiful supply of food, and if the full-flowing periods of an ambassador were vicarious of medicine, certainly our poor soldiers at Scutari who have died from want of food and want of medicine should now be above ground, healthy and well-nourished men. We published yesterday a series of papers relative to the supply through lord STRATFORD DE REDCLIFFE, our Ambassador at Constantinople, of articles necessary for the comfort of the sick and wounded in the English Military Hospitals at Scutari. As the first act of a tragedy, this reads well enough. It is highly right and proper to a poet who cultivates this branch of the art to give none but faint indications of the terrible calamities which are to overwhelm the dramatis personæ in the concluding scenes of his drama. It would never do if he showed us at once the stage covered with mangled corpses; the ensanguined dagger here, the drained poison-bowl there. No, let all at first go merry as a marriage ball, however funereally it may end. Thus it is as touching this batch of correspondence. Had we not counted our hecatombs; had not English families by thousands and thousands wept over their dead, who died not in the battle-field, and with the halo of a soldier's glory around their paling brows, but who sank exhausted in the midst of stench and pollution unutterable, starved to extinction, and unprovided with the medical aids and comforts their situation might require — had we not, in a word, read the evidence of our own correspondents, and of such credible witnesses as Messrs. STAFFORD and SIDNEY OSBORNE — we should say of this correspondence that it is satisfactory in the extreme. Let us take the thing at the beginning — the end we unfortunately know. To be sure, it takes off something from the smack and relish of the graceful phrase in use among official penmen that we do know the end. It is amidst the tombs, — it is in a rank graveyard, that we take these letters in hand.

The Duke of NEWCASTLE heard as far back as October of last year that one of the English hospitals at Constantinople was very inadequately supplied with bedsteads, mattresses, and other comforts. It takes off from the keen edge of our confidence in the official system that our Minister of War did not hear of such deficiencies through his own accredited agents, but was left to chance sources of information. However, as soon as his mind became enlightened he wrote off to Lord STRATFORD DE REDCLIFFE, giving to that distinguished diplomatist powers which we may at once describe as plenary, for the purchase of any articles at Constantinople which might seem necessary for the service of the hospitals. So far the Duke, who with a handsome compliment upon Lord STRATFORD'S humanity, &c., transmitted the letter to Lord CLARENDON for his approval. The Foreign Secretary entirely approved the proceedings of his colleague: he indeed was confident that "Lord STRATFORD'S own feelings of humanity, and the deep sympathy he entertained for the brave men now suffering from the casualties of war, would have induced him even to anticipate the wishes of HER MAJESTY'S Government, that everything should be done to alleviate their condition." The united letters of these two high functionaries reached Lord STRATFORD about the end of October, and he straightway wrote off to Dr. MENZIES, as the principal medical authority at the hospital, to inquire into the nature of existing deficiencies. "Aware of the deep interest which the Earl of CLARENDON must naturally take in the welfare of those whom sickness on service or wounds in battle have consigned for a time to our Military Hospitals at Scutari," the Ambassador encloses back to England Dr. MENZIES' report. Could anything be more regular in appearance, more entirely satisfactory? Nor can it be said that Dr. MENZIES was hasty or inconsiderate in the manner of getting up his return. He did not dash off in vague generalities, but first consulted with the officers at the head of the apothecary and purveying depôts as to what amount of supplies and stores might be required for the comfort and sustenance of the sick and wounded. Such was the question Dr. MENZIES put, and from the answers he obtained he felt himself justified in writing back, "As far as our present wants extend, we are abundantly supplied, and more" (qy., wants?) "expected daily from England and Varna." A few trifling matters, indeed, might be requisite; a further loan of Turkish bedding and utensils — it might be a few stoves in the winter — but, on the whole, the hospital wagged merrily enough, — that is, as much so as was compatible with the nature of such an establishment.

It is needless to say that Lord STRATFORD did at once cause to be supplied — at least we presume so — the trifling articles noted as deficiencies in Dr. MENZIES' letter. The Ambassador, in a very affecting communication bearing date November 15, informs his Government of the result. Not only has he called upon the SULTAN to make the necessary sacrifices, but the sacrifices have actually been made. Nor were Lord STRATFORD'S exertions only of a public nature. He tried to avail himself of such "means of detail" — we copy his own expression — as might best contribute to the success of his beneficent endeavours. The hospital was visited by himself — we presume this was the occasion upon which the medical officers turned out in full costume — but Lord STRATFORD returned not; for

"Any advantage which might have resulted from a repetition of my own personal appearance in the hospitals has been superseded by the attendance of Lady Stratford, who, availing herself of the presence of Miss Nightingale and other persons of her sex, has visited the hospitals, and, on my behalf, arranged the leading points, in consort with the local authorities. I may, nevertheless, add that on the 12th inst. I went to town for the purpose of crossing over to Scutari, but was constrained to relinquish my intention by the impracticable state of the weather and the necessity of returning home for other business requiring my immediate attention.

"I have now the satisfaction to state that, according to the reports addressed to me, both the Sultan and his Ministers have displayed an unreserved readiness to comply with my requisitions — that the Sultan, besides giving up to our use the reserved Imperial apartments in the barracks and hospital, has directed his Ministers to withhold no supplies which we may ask and they can furnish; and that, with the exception of two or three articles requiring preparation, the whole arrangement is in prompt and satisfactory progress.

"Official men of understanding and activity are, as I understand, performing their duty with zeal; the patients appear to be greatly comforted by the gentle and unrelaxing assiduity of the female nurses, and there are private gentlemen who do honour to human nature by personally devoting themselves with the most generous sympathy to the relief and assistance of their gallant fellow-countrymen."

It is satisfactory at least to find that the Ambassador — unlike official men in general — really recognize the merits of Miss NIGHTINGALE and her companions, and of the gentlemen who visited the hospitals with the hope, at least, of doing good. Pity it was, indeed, that Lord STRATFORD should have suffered himself to be so lightly diverted from his intention, for now we know what the awful result has been. Lord STRATFORD, we admit, as far as his interference went at all, was the victim of a deception — there can be no doubt of that. Should it, however, have been within the region of possibilities that Englishmen should perish monthly by hundreds, ay, by thousands, in a military hospital within reach of a British embassy? There was Lord STRATFORD face to face, as one may say, with the tragedy; but for him it had no existence. It is useless to dwell longer upon the past as far as the brave men are concerned who have been called to their account; but can we hope that at least their fate has furnished us with a warning for the future? It is all much the same. The other day the remainder of the Guards embarked for the Crimea, with a plentiful supply of comfortable winter apparel, each man with a bearskin, a thick knapsack, and Brown Bess. Furs in August, light duck in January, and routine everywhere!

 
     
 
 
     
       
 
Copyright © The Mediadrome 2000. All Rights Reserved.
 
 
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy